About Us

Most insurance agencies sell on price.

They know you’re budget conscious, and they want to give you the ‘best’ quote in order to close the sale. Most likely, when price is a determining factor, it’s at the expense of getting the protection you really need.

That’s how 1 in 6 adults in the U.S. ends up under-insured and unprotected. And most of them don’t even know it.

You need an insurance partner who cares more about listening to your needs than closing a sale. At the end of the day, there is no value in paying for the wrong coverage, no matter what the cost.

We’re committed to providing protection you can count on.

At BenefitSource, we were founded on the principle that if you don’t have the coverage you need, price doesn’t matter.

Every person, every family and every business has different needs. When it comes to coverage, one size does not fit all. And that’s why we look at each of our clients as an individual.

The things that matter to you are important to us, too.

We understand that there are things in your life that you can’t afford to lose. We’ll help you prepare for the unexpected by analyzing your unique situation and providing an individualized plan. Optimal coverage, at rates you can live with.

Independence matters to us – and to you.

We always have been – and always will be – an independent agency. That means we’re not tied to a single brand of insurance, and can design coverage that is truly right for our clients.

There are up to twenty insurance companies to choose from at BenefitSource, and because we represent multiple brands, we can compare coverage and prices in order to find the best fit.

That’s how we can ensure that you will always get the best combination of coverage, price and service. We are professionals. We are value-hunters. But most of all, we’re good listeners.

Peace of mind

Having the right insurance means being confident that nobody can take away what is important in your life.

Understanding your policy is just the beginning. Your policies must work together to provide you with comprehensive protection.

For more than 10 years, we’ve been acting as trusted advisors for our clients, designing policies that provide them with security they can count on.

Our satisfied clients

I have had the pleasure of working with Nicole at Benefit Source for over 5 years now. When dealing with the complex intricacies of insurance, it is important and a comfort to know I have a competent agent on my side to help me navigate the waters. I’m confident I have someone who can always provide sound advice and know what type of coverage I need and also, as importantly, what coverage I don’t need. She has written business liability, home, auto, life and workers comp policies for me. In an age where most agents are impersonal or being replaced with automated internet sites, I am happy my agent breaks the mold and exceeds my expectations. I see our relationship
lasting well into the future.

– Blake L.

I would like to take this opportunity to express my complete satisfaction with the services my agent, Cindy Lux-Reid has performed for us over an extended period of time. She has made numerous changes in the coverages of our autos and home promptly and cheerfully as we have required to keep our policy properly updated. I would be quite happy to refer any potential new client to Cindy and Benefitsource Insurance.

– Alan H.

Working with Benefit Source and my agent, Travis vonBartheld has been a great and easy experience. Travis is extremely knowledgeable and was able to secure more comprehensive policies for me at a much lower price than my previous carrier. Travis is always available to help answer any questions I have. I am very happy I was referred to Benefit Source and will continue to refer my friends and family.

– Allison G.